Debunking the myth: Were people really smaller in the past?

Ah, the eternal vintage question: "why is everything so tiny?!" If you've ever wrestled a gorgeous '70s dress over your shoulders and lost, you've felt it. But here's the truth — people back then weren't all pocket-sized. The real reasons are way more interesting (and way less personal).

Vanity sizing is messing with your head

This is the big one. Clothing sizes have quietly inflated for decades — what was labeled a size 12 in the 1950s is closer to a modern 4 or 6. Brands realized we feel good buying smaller numbers, so the numbers crept down while the actual measurements stayed put (or grew). A vintage "14" can fit like a contemporary 8. Always, always go by the measurements, not the tag.

Survivorship bias: the small stuff just… survived

Think about which clothes make it 50+ years. Often the ones that didn't get worn to death — the "I'll fit into it someday" dress that hung untouched, or pieces that were simply too small to wear out. Larger everyday clothes got worn, mended, and worn again until they fell apart. So the vintage that's left skews smaller — not because everyone was smaller, but because that's what survived.

There was no universal size chart

Standardized sizing barely existed for big chunks of the 20th century. Tons of vintage was home-sewn or tailored to one specific body, and store sizing varied wildly brand to brand. A number on a 1968 label is basically a vibe, not a measurement.

Hand-me-downs and alterations

Clothes used to get passed around and taken in constantly. A dress might've started bigger and been tailored down for a younger sibling — so the piece in your hands may not even reflect its original size.

So what do you actually do?

Measure, measure, measure — bust, waist, hips, flat across — and compare to a garment that already fits you. And a good tailor is your best friend; letting something out or nipping it in is how the pros make vintage work. We measure everything carefully and carry inclusive sizes from XXS to 5XL, because everyone deserves the good stuff.


Ready to find your perfect fit? Browse the shop — inclusive sizes XXS to 5XL, measured and ready.

Keep reading: What size am I in vintage clothes?

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Nope. Couldn't find it.

Easiest upcycle ever!

Turn a square of fabric into a top with basically two cuts. The easiest upcycle/sew there is.

Let's make a wrap dress together

Come make a wrap dress with me — no pattern, just tracing one I already love and tweaking the bits I'd change. Cutting, finishing edges, straps, and options for an elastic waist and finished neckline.

Beginning sewing: supply list

My friend is learning to sew and had one big question: what do I actually need to get started? So I'm answering it — the real supply list, no fluff, plus what the internet will try to sell you that...

Yet Another Vintage Haul

Come dig through the latest treasures! A big pile of thrifted vintage — barkcloth cuties, a metal-zipper dress with immaculate vibes, prairie-core, cottage-core, and a jumpsuit you are not ready fo...

DIY Tie-Side Pants & Crop Top Tutorial (No Pattern!)

Grab a bed sheet and a little string, because we're making a whole two-piece outfit — no pattern, no zipper, no crying. This beginner-friendly tutorial walks you through every cut and every seam fo...

How to shop on the Whatnot app

New to Whatnot? I've been buying and selling on there for years, so let me demystify it. It's basically a live auction site where you can shop hundreds of categories in real time.

Let's make a boxy quilt jacket together

Grab your quilt (or that thrifted blanket you've been hoarding) and let's make a boxy quilt jacket together in this cozy, real-time sew-along.

Real-time fabric unboxing

An unfiltered, real-time reaction to unboxing a haul of fabric, including some Lilly Pulitzer surprises.

Let's make a kaftan!

A loose, beginner-friendly kaftan you can make from a curtain panel, tablecloth, or any big rectangle of fabric.

Yet another thrift haul

A cozy run through a fresh pile of Goodwill bins finds, grails, and future upcycle projects.

How to shop on the Whatnot app

New to Whatnot? Here's your quick rundown: what it is, how to set up your account, and how to actually have fun (and win stuff) in a live show. Think Home Shopping Network + eBay, but the baby love...

Let's make a boxy quilt jacket together

Come make a big, cozy, boxy quilt jacket with me — pure vibes, minimal cutting, and a whole lot of "use your imagination." I eyeballed the whole thing from one quilt: one-piece body, oversized slee...

It's another freaking thrift haul

Another joyful thrift haul, this time courtesy of JR, who came home with a pile of finds to film.

Here's a little thrift haul

JR brought home a massive haul of vintage clothing, fabric, and linens. Come see every dreamy piece.

Obsessed with this needle reminder gadget!

An ADHD-friendly sewing hack: the peel-and-stick "So Remind Me" needle reminder that keeps you from sewing with the wrong needle.